tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2106815346229702986.post8965678798261193910..comments2024-03-21T00:17:37.281-07:00Comments on sherapop's salon de parfum: Entry #6: A Philosophical Lexicon for PerfumistasUnknownnoreply@blogger.comBlogger6125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2106815346229702986.post-84365494925769106772013-04-04T08:56:34.233-07:002013-04-04T08:56:34.233-07:00My apologies! I'll get back to work! ;-)My apologies! I'll get back to work! ;-)sherapophttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14116821928196122529noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2106815346229702986.post-46600542570755227252013-04-04T05:51:33.998-07:002013-04-04T05:51:33.998-07:00A day without an entry #, is like a day without su...A day without an entry #, is like a day without sunshine. Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2106815346229702986.post-76714506905998820592013-04-03T14:48:49.573-07:002013-04-03T14:48:49.573-07:00This comment seems unduly hostile to me, however, ...This comment seems unduly hostile to me, however, because its content is relevant, I have published it. <br /><br />You are asking an age-old Socratic question, it seems to me. Or perhaps this is more obviously an example straight out of Plato: the allegory of the Cave, according to which we base our judgments of things on the appearances which are cast by sophists upon the wall of the Cave. What we see are mere shadows, not reality, but we bellow out our opinions as though they conveyed some sort of objective truth.<br /><br />I think that in the age of media, where marketing is omnipresent, Plato's allegory of the Cave is more telling than ever, and I thank you for raising this point. Can we encounter a perfume such as Chanel no 5 without having been affected by the barrage of advertisements? I do not see how, although in my case, the advertising has not succeeded in its intended goal. In fact, it has had the opposite effect: convincing me to believe that the gushing about this perfume has a lot more to do with associations with Marilyn Monroe, Catherine Deneuve, and generally perceived to be rich, glamorous, and sophisticated women...<br /><br />Of course, someone might argue that I am just as affected by the marketing hype, and react to it by simplemindedly denying the value of the product being hyped--by dismissing it out of hand for the hype alone! <br /><br />The challenge becomes recognizing that the hype is hype but developing the capacity to judge the perfume (or whatever) more or less on its own terms, rather than either celebrating it simply because it has been associated with celebrities of one or another kind (and they could be perfumers, too, the way things are going these days!), or denouncing it on essentially "emperor's new clothes" grounds. <br /><br />It seems to me that Q (above) was trying to say something along these lines. There is a difference between someone who looks at the top ten board at Sephora and says, "Wow, those are the best perfumes, so I'd better buy one of them," and someone whose response is, "This is the swill being bought these days?" Perhaps the best response is simply to take note that the top ten board is just a list of the bestselling perfumes, no more and no less significant than that. <br /><br />I should however admit that I have no objection to people enjoying perfume as a vicarious connection to some otherwise inaccessible person, or because it is popular, or because it makes them feel glamorous or sophisticated--or whatever. <br /><br />Different things make different people happy!<br /><br />Thank you for this relevant comment! ;-) sherapophttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14116821928196122529noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2106815346229702986.post-45008884743485436542013-04-03T14:25:25.583-07:002013-04-03T14:25:25.583-07:00Hello, Simone, and thank you for your observations...Hello, Simone, and thank you for your observations!<br /><br />Yes, there is no doubt that we change our views about different perfumes over time. We tend to believe that our latest view is better than our former view (that's why we changed!), but it is difficult to see how we might validate the superiority of our current view. It is true that we can learn a lot about perfume, as in any other realm, and we may feel more sophisticated in our judgments, but the crucial evaluation itself (do I like it?) does not seem to depend upon our knowledge of facts about the perfume.<br /><br />I have encountered plenty of people who profess hatred or love of certain perfumes, but your point is well taken, that perhaps they need to modify the dose! Some would say that the only acceptable dose of their most detested perfume should be imperceptibly small! ;-)sherapophttps://www.blogger.com/profile/14116821928196122529noreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2106815346229702986.post-54930780581504431812013-04-03T11:54:51.939-07:002013-04-03T11:54:51.939-07:00Of course there is a constant bombarding that effe...Of course there is a constant bombarding that effects the "dumb" people. But oh no, it has NO effect on Q. Q is too smart to be a victim. Advertising has no effect on "smart" people. <br /><br />Why are so many smart people so.....um.....smart?Anonymousnoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-2106815346229702986.post-56342251455635998032013-04-02T08:24:05.621-07:002013-04-02T08:24:05.621-07:00I think perfume preferences has also an age factor...I think perfume preferences has also an age factor that leads the nose during a life time.<br />I also think that we can be educated to choose what we prefer.<br />And there is the constant bombarding marketing to influence one's nose - not my case, but many are victims.<br />As per Chanel - I detested it for a while, than I loved it for a while...strange...<br />Poison - I always found this perfume a mistake and a slap on the face...but some people find it amazing...go figure...<br />I used to find citrusy fragrances boring. I love more complexed and usually dirtier fragrances..but lately I found the beauty in them...<br />I think we can't really frame perfumes in a label such as love it or hate it...Chanel Nº5 is a good example for me. I found out that when I wear a tiny drop of it it smells really wonderful on my skin. But it has to be minimal....+ Q Perfume Bloghttp://www.maiqueperfume.blogspot.comnoreply@blogger.com